“Meet the Press” jumps the shark


photo NY Times

Over the summer it was  rumored that NBC was going to drop David Gregory from the Meet the Press moderator’s chair because of dramatically declining ratings. Would that they had.

Except for FOX appearances, Mitt Romney has been AWOL from network news interview programs. On Sunday, host David Gregory missed  opportunity after opportunity to quiz Romney meaningfully on his first appearance on that show in years. It was a fingernails-on-blackboard experience.  

Maybe Mitt’s campaign  negotiated with the producers to have the whole first segment be more  People magazine personal or else he wouldn’t appear.  If so, shouldn’t Gregory have announced that?  If not, don’t waste our time!  Disclosure of onerous ground rules might have explained what happened.

The interview seemed like ‘Larry King does the Romneys.’ He threw softball after softball to Ann and Mitt.  When they said they were not in the race to slow the rise of the ocean or cure the planet but to help people, Gregory could have asked, “but aren’t there any human consequences of environmental degradation.” Alas, he did not.

Then there was this hardball:  Are you proud to the the first Mormon nominee and perhaps the first Mormon President?  Did he expect “no” for an answer? 

The second half was supposed to be the substantive part.  Gregory asked about Romney’s fiscal plans and got the usual vague answer that he’d bring down the top rates, limit deductions and exemptions – just at the high end (that was something new) – and maintain defense at a certain percentage of GDP.  He also said the middle class shouldn’t have to pay taxes on interest and dividends. 

There were at least three opportunities to push Romney on what the deductions and exemptions were that, if elected President, he’d eliminate, but Gregory couldn’t get the candidate to be specific and seemed to throw in the towel. It must be like Nixon’s secret plan to end the war: trust me.

When Romney said that “there’s nothing wrong with compromise, but I won’t abandon my principles,”  it was another opening to move beyond cliche. Again, Gregory failed to get Romney to explain, in light of his gubernatorial experience, how he might compromise on principles in order to break congressional gridlock and make deals in D.C. 

On health care, Gregory allowed Romney to say oh, yes, he’d replace ObamaCare with his own plan, which would preserve coverage for pre-existing conditions, but he never even asked him if that were required how he’d pay for it.

Romney said he hoped to appoint justices to the Supreme Court who would overturn Roe v. Wade. But Gregory never asked him about the co-chair of his Justice Advisory Committee,  Robert Bork, or put up on the screen some of Bork’s outlier constitutional views, asking the candidate whether those views were consonant with his own.

On to foreign policy. Romney said Obama’s greatest failure is in a nuclear Iran.  Gregory should have asked how Romney would respond if Israel moves on Iran unilaterally.  He did not.  Gregory did ask if Obama’s failure on Iran wasn’t the same as George W. Bush’s policy, and didn’t that fail as well?  Romney dodged it, and Gregory couldn’t deliver.  He asked at one point where should the red line be in terms of possible U.S. response but never followed up when an answer was not forthcoming.

With time left for one more question, Gregory asked Romney how he would handle losing if, in fact, he lost the election.  Come on!

To make matters worse,   at the end of this embarrassing interview, Gregory teased the up-coming panel discussion, saying with a straight face, “How did Governor Romney change the debate in this campaign with this interview.”  Oh, really?

Late Meet the Press anchor Tim Russert must be rolling over in his grave.  Yes, he left big shoes to fill.  But David Gregory is not the one to do it! (Time for Chuck Todd?)

I welcome your comments in the section below.

3 thoughts on ““Meet the Press” jumps the shark

  1. Charles Sanderson

    David Gregory is simply awful. The moment that stands out for me (recently) is his interruption of a substantive discussion among his guests to announce that he had two cell phones that he kept next to his bed at night. He constantly trims his sails to remain safely within the tiny confines of Washington Conventional Wisdom, and I don’t ever remember his asking a question that suggested he had read and understood a complex policy issue.

    I have reservations about Chuck Todd. He is smart, but his strengths — his ability to process data — often leaves him captive to that data. The suggestion for Rachel Maddow is a possibility, but the person on MSNBC who has been impressing me lately is Alex Wagner.


  2. Nancy Nizel

    This one should go to the network, NBC.
    You certainly speak for me on this one.

    On 9/10/12 10:32 PM, “Marjorie Arons-Barron” wrote:

    > aronsbarron posted: ” photo NY Times Over the summer it was� rumored that NBC > was going to drop David Gregory from the Meet the Press moderator’s chair > because of dramatically declining rating” >


  3. Ellen Hoffman

    I choose Rachel Maddow to replace him. Even Katie Couric would be better. Look how she got Sarah Palin, although Sarah pretty much did it to herself.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s