Biden’s nine-word unforced error

“Will no one rid me of this meddlesome priest?” King Henry II is said to have muttered out loud, grumbling about Thomas a Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury. Henry wasn’t ordering anyone to whack the troublesome Becket, but four knights who overheard what they assumed to be the King’s wish, rode off to Canterbury and killed the lofty cleric. The story has been written about for centuries, and it came to mind immediately when President Biden, wrapping up an otherwise impactful speech in Poland, said of thug Vladimir Putin, “For God’s sake, this man cannot remain in power.” 

A gaffe, as Michael Kingsley famously said, is when a politician accidentally tells the truth. Was Biden signalling to other nations or individuals that he wants a regime change in Russia? Since the 19th century, well before Vietnam, Chile, Iran and Iraq, the United States has had a history of meddling in other countries. I don’t think the President was advocating that, at least not at a conscious level. As for the subconscious, who among us (save for certain Fox News prime time anchors) would not wish Putin to be ousted, even vaporized. Surely, there is no place in a civilized world for such a war criminal, butcher, brute.

Perhaps Biden was reflecting how deeply touched by the meetings he had just had with some of the 3.7 million refugees from Ukraine, his having heard so many heartbreaking stories. His pain and frustration at Putin’s pitiless barbarism may have just spilled over. But going off script has consequences.

Putin has repeatedly asserted that NATO is trying to deny Russia’s sovereignty. This, despite NATO’s mission being a defensive one. Biden’s gaffe is fodder for Putin’s propaganda machine, and the seeming challenge to Putin’s legitimacy, even to his manhood, fuels his rage and instability. We can’t afford to fuel that fire.

Politically, the White House having to walk back Biden’s comment worsens the sense that he lacks discipline. His approval rating is at the lowest level of his Presidency, and an event like this doesn’t help.

Finally, the President himself has managed to distract people at home and abroad from his own stirring prose, powerfully scripted and, up to the very end, well delivered – some say, even Churchillian. Focused, strong and unwavering, this was a speech with historical threads tying together an American President’s role as leader of the free world. Let’s not forget that Biden has rebuilt the international alliances and our free world standing grossly undermined by his predecessor. With Ukraine, he has made the right moves, despite Republican and other criticism of his pace in doing so.

When it comes to Ukraine, Biden may have fluffed, but he hasn’t flinched. There are still many open questions. What happens if Putin uses chemical, biological weapons, or tactical nuclear weapons? How should and will Biden and NATO respond “proportionately?” What will stepped up punitive measures look like if Putin intensifies the decimation of Ukraine? Should NATO, despite the risks, at least provide a humanitarian no-fly zone?

Putin knows only one thing: raw aggression. What are the American people prepared to do in this bloody battle of autocracy versus democracy? We take for granted the freedoms we enjoy at home. How far are we willing to go to defend those principles abroad, when we are so divided at home?

I welcome your feedback in the comments section. To be alerted when a new blog is posted, click on “Follow’ on the home page on marjoriearonsbarron.com.

3 thoughts on “Biden’s nine-word unforced error

  1. Robert Fishman

    Margie – Biden has a history of gaffes, none as bad as this one. Putin has framed his actions as protecting Russia from the West, especially the USA as the enemy, not Ukraine as much. Biden’s off script words fit into Purim’s narrative and will undoubtedly further inflame his sense of grievance against the West. Bob

    Bob Fishman Rfishman423@gmail.com Cell 617-875-7736

    >

    Like

  2. Connie Kantar

    Margie, I agree with you that it would have been better if Biden (if he were a perfect person), had not uttered that heartfelt phrase. He’d had intense, emotion-filled , highly important and complex meetings, decisions – or non decisions regarding the direction of this horrible war…and then meeting with some of the 3.5 million refugees…I think he just couldn’t stop this very real desire (which millions the world over say again snd again ) from spilling out in words.. A very human reaction.

    Like

  3. Marjorie and James,

    Check this out. Worth watching. https://www.belfercenter.org/publication/negotiating-vladimir-putin-video-advice-five-former-us-secretaries-state

    Very best,

    Paul

    On Sun, Mar 27, 2022 at 8:19 PM Marjorie Arons-Barron wrote:

    > aronsbarron posted: ” “Will no one rid me of this meddlesome priest?” King > Henry II is said to have muttered out loud, grumbling about Thomas a > Becket, Archbishop of Canterbury. Henry wasn’t ordering anyone to whack the > troublesome Becket, but four knights who overheard what” >

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s